12th grade Science rubric for high school, 5 criteria, 4 levels
| Criteria | Level 4 | Level 3 | Level 2 | Level 1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thesis Clarity and Appropriateness | A thesis appropriate to the writing prompt is implied but may not be well stated or focused. Main points are somewhat relevant, though some key ideas may be missing or irrelevant. | There is one clearly-stated, well-focused thesis that addresses the writing prompt. Main points are relevant. Writer does not include any extraneous content. | There is one thesis that is appropriate to the writing prompt. Main points are relevant. Writer includes very little, if any, extraneous content. | Thesis does not appropriately address the writing prompt or is missing. Main points may not be relevant and key ideas may be missing. |
| Evidence Support and Relevance | Main ideas are well-supported by carefully selected and fully developed, accurate details, examples, evidence, or information. | Main ideas are adequately supported by details, examples, evidence, or information, with few lapses and/or inaccuracies. | Main ideas are somewhat supported by details, examples, evidence, or information, with some lapses and/or inaccuracies. | Main ideas are inadequately supported by details, examples, evidence, or information, with many lapses and/or inaccuracies. |
| Organizational Effectiveness | The opening is inviting/interesting. Ideas are presented in a highly effective, logical order. The conclusion is strong. Smooth transitions are employed between ideas. | Essay features a purposeful opening and adequately effective conclusion. Ideas are presented in a predominantly logical order, and most transitions are smooth. | Opening and/or conclusion are present, but with limited effectiveness. Attempt has been made to order ideas logically, with some key lapses. Transitions may be neglected. | Organization of essay impedes, rather than facilitates, understanding. Ideas may be haphazardly presented and opening/conclusion/transitions are neglected. |
| Language Fluency and Appropriateness | Uses language that is fluent and precise, with an evident sense of voice, awareness of audience and purpose, and the ability to vary sentence structure effectively. | Uses basic but appropriate language, with some sense of voice, awareness of audience and purpose, and some attempt to vary sentence structure. | Uses language that is vague or imprecise for the audience or purpose, with little sense of voice, and a limited ability with varying sentence structure. | Uses language that is unsuitable for the audience and purpose, with little or no awareness of sentence structure variety. |
| Grammar Control and Consistency | Demonstrates consistent control of grammar, punctuation, spelling & usage, exhibiting only occasional errors that do not hinder comprehension. | Demonstrates primarily consistent control of grammar, punctuation, spelling & usage, exhibiting some errors or lapses that do not overly hinder comprehension. | Demonstrates limited control of grammar, punctuation, spelling & usage, exhibiting frequent errors that make comprehension difficult. | Demonstrates little or no control of grammar, punctuation, spelling & usage, seriously inhibiting comprehension. |
Save your own copy of this rubric to edit and grade with.