Graduate English rubric for college, 8 criteria, 4 levels
| Criteria | Level 4 | Level 3 | Level 2 | Level 1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thorough Introduction | Submission includes a thorough introduction to the identified county with no missing information or detail regarding the description of the target population. | Includes a clear introduction to the identified county with minor omissions in detail regarding the description of the target population. | Presents a basic introduction to the identified county but lacks significant details about the target population, resulting in some unclear aspects. | Provides a minimal introduction to the identified county with major omissions and inaccuracies regarding the description of the target population. |
| Complete Determination | Submission includes all necessary information for determining the purpose and scope of the needs assessment, with no oversights or omissions. | Submission includes most necessary information for determining the purpose and scope of the needs assessment, with minor oversights or omissions that do not significantly impact understanding. | Submission includes some necessary information for determining the purpose and scope of the needs assessment, but contains several oversights or omissions that hinder clarity. | Submission includes limited information for determining the purpose and scope of the needs assessment, with significant oversights or omissions that severely impact understanding. |
| Thorough Data Analysis | Submission includes a thorough secondary data collection and analysis process and description, with attention to all key aspects, an above-adequate data collection strategy, exceptional data interpretation and presentation, described linkages between data, and high-quality effort. | Includes a comprehensive secondary data collection and analysis process with attention to most key aspects, a satisfactory data collection strategy, competent data interpretation and presentation, some linkages between data, and a solid effort. | Includes a basic secondary data collection and analysis process with attention to some key aspects, a limited data collection strategy, basic data interpretation and presentation, minimal linkages between data, and an adequate effort. | Includes a minimal secondary data collection and analysis process with little attention to key aspects, an ineffective data collection strategy, unclear data interpretation and presentation, no linkages between data, and a lack of effort. |
| Comprehensive Plan | Submission includes a thorough data collection plan with detail on assessment tools and resources, sound and justifiable tool selections, inclusion of both quantitative and qualitative methods, and an evaluation plan that aligns with program goals and objectives. | Includes a comprehensive data collection plan with some detail on assessment tools and resources, mostly sound tool selections, a mix of quantitative and qualitative methods, and an evaluation plan that generally aligns with program goals and objectives. | Includes a basic data collection plan with limited detail on assessment tools and resources, some questionable tool selections, primarily quantitative methods with minimal qualitative input, and an evaluation plan that somewhat aligns with program goals and objectives. | Includes a vague data collection plan with little to no detail on assessment tools and resources, poor tool selections, reliance on either quantitative or qualitative methods without balance, and an evaluation plan that does not align with program goals and objectives. |
| Thorough Overview | Submission provides a thorough overview of the needs in the community/target population, a thorough description of the needs supported by data, and no omissions or oversights. | Provides a clear overview of the needs in the community/target population, with a description of the needs supported by data, though some minor details may be missing or overlooked. | Offers a basic overview of the needs in the community/target population, with limited description supported by data, and several omissions or oversights present. | Presents a vague overview of the needs in the community/target population, with minimal or no description supported by data, and significant omissions or oversights evident. |
| Detailed Description | Submission provides a thorough, detailed, yet concise description of the focus of a future program. Conclusions fully align with the data presented, the purpose of the needs assessment, and the needs of the community. | Provides a clear and detailed description of the focus of a future program, with conclusions that generally align with the data presented and the needs of the community, though some minor inconsistencies may be present. | Offers a basic description of the focus of a future program, with conclusions that partially align with the data presented and the needs of the community, but lacks depth and detail in several areas. | Presents a vague or incomplete description of the focus of a future program, with conclusions that do not align with the data presented or the needs of the community, showing significant gaps in understanding. |
| Effective Communication | Submission effectively, clearly, and meaningfully communicates the results of the needs assessment and focus for the rationale, with no important omissions or oversights. The message is of high quality, visually appealing, and effective. | Submission clearly communicates the results of the needs assessment and focus for the rationale, with minor omissions or oversights. The message is of good quality, visually appealing, and generally effective. | Submission communicates the results of the needs assessment and focus for the rationale, but lacks clarity and contains several omissions or oversights. The message is of basic quality, somewhat visually appealing, and has limited effectiveness. | Submission fails to effectively communicate the results of the needs assessment and focus for the rationale, with significant omissions and oversights. The message is of low quality, visually unappealing, and ineffective. |
| Excellent Formatting | Submission follows all formatting requirements with very limited formatting errors, provides citations, and has only minor grammatical or spelling errors. | Submission follows most formatting requirements with some formatting errors, provides citations, and has a few grammatical or spelling errors. | Submission follows some formatting requirements but contains several formatting errors, provides limited citations, and has multiple grammatical or spelling errors. | Submission does not follow formatting requirements, lacks citations, and contains numerous grammatical or spelling errors. |
Save your own copy of this rubric to edit and grade with.